Correspondence  |   January 2018
In Reply
Author Notes
  • University of Iowa, Iowa City, Iowa (E.O.B.).
  • (Accepted for publication September 28, 2017.)
    (Accepted for publication September 28, 2017.)×
Article Information
Correspondence   |   January 2018
In Reply
Anesthesiology 1 2018, Vol.128, 225. doi:
Anesthesiology 1 2018, Vol.128, 225. doi:
We appreciate Montes et al.’s interest in our article. In their 2015 Anesthesiology article, the authors analyzed data from 2,929 patients who were candidates for inguinal hernia repair (men), hysterectomy (women), or thoracotomy (men) under general, regional, or local anesthesia with sedation. Four hundred and two patients (all male) underwent thoracotomy. 1  Approximately 4.4 months after surgery, 37.6% of the thoracotomy patients had chronic postsurgical pain. We think the size of the study—nearly 3,000 patients enrolled—is quite remarkable.
To summarize the conclusions from Montes et al., they created a multivariate model that included all three types of surgeries where the outcome of interest was the presence of chronic postsurgical pain at 4 months after surgery. According to their model, the following variables were associated with chronic postsurgical pain at 4 months after surgery: (1) surgical procedure, (2) patient age, (3) physical health (Short Form Health Survey-12), (4) mental health (Short Form Health Survey-12), (5) preoperative pain in the surgical field, and (6) preoperative pain in another area.
In our study, we enrolled only thoracic surgery patients (both thoracotomy and video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery) without any restriction on sex. In addition, following the recommendation of the Initiative on Methods, Measurement, and Pain Assessment in Clinical Trials group,2  we excluded those patients with preexisting chronic pain problems in the chest area. Preoperative pain in the surgical area and other areas may be different for thoracotomy versus hernia and hysterectomy patients. Thoracotomy patients generally do not have preoperative pain in the chest. In our study, preoperative pain at rest was univariately associated with the presence of pain at 6 months after thoracic surgery. However, in the presence of acute pain in the multivariate model, this effect was not significant. We measured preoperative physical function and preoperative mental health with multiple assessments.3  It is likely that those patients with preoperative pain related to their surgical procedure have other psychosocial risk factors before and after surgery, thus limiting comparable studies. There may be unknown risk factors associated with chronic pain for hernia and hysterectomy patients that are not present in thoracic surgery patients, both male and female. In summary, our study and the study of Montes et al. are quite different and we cannot make direct comparisons between the factors in their final multivariate model versus our model. Differences between Althaus et al. and our study are even greater, since only two patients had thoracic surgery in their study.
We recognized our limitations as noted by Montes et al. We also noted consistencies with other similar studies.4,5  When determining risk factors of postsurgical chronic pain from multiple surgeries, mixing different types of surgeries has a number of limitations, including sex, preoperative symptoms, chronic pain in other areas, and psychosocial risk factors. We agree with Montes et al.’s conclusion that larger, comprehensive, prospective observational studies are needed to confirm and to understand the mechanisms leading to chronic pain after thoracic surgery.
Competing Interests
The authors declare no competing interests.
Emine Ozgur Bayman, Ph.D., Timothy J. Brennan, M.D., Ph.D. University of Iowa, Iowa City, Iowa (E.O.B.).
Montes, A, Roca, G, Sabate, S, Lao, JI, Navarro, A, Cantillo, J, Canet, J GENDOLCAT Study Group: Genetic and clinical factors associated with chronic postsurgical pain after hernia repair, hysterectomy, and thoracotomy: A two-year multicenter cohort study. Anesthesiology 2015; 122:1123–41 [Article] [PubMed]
Gewandter, JS, Dworkin, RH, Turk, DC, Farrar, JT, Fillingim, RB, Gilron, I, Markman, JD, Oaklander, AL, Polydefkis, MJ, Raja, SN, Robinson, JP, Woolf, CJ, Ziegler, D, Ashburn, MA, Burke, LB, Cowan, P, George, SZ, Goli, V, Graff, OX, Iyengar, S, Jay, GW, Katz, J, Kehlet, H, Kitt, RA, Kopecky, EA, Malamut, R, McDermott, MP, Palmer, P, Rappaport, BA, Rauschkolb, C, Steigerwald, I, Tobias, J, Walco, GA Research design considerations for chronic pain prevention clinical trials: IMMPACT recommendations. Pain 2015; 156:1184–97 [Article] [PubMed]
Bayman, EO, Parekh, KR, Keech, J, Selte, A, Brennan, TJ A prospective study of chronic pain after thoracic surgery. Anesthesiology 2017; 126:938–51 [Article] [PubMed]
Katz, J, Jackson, M, Kavanagh, BP, Sandler, AN Acute pain after thoracic surgery predicts long-term post-thoracotomy pain. Clin J Pain 1996; 12:50–5 [Article] [PubMed]
Yarnitsky, D, Crispel, Y, Eisenberg, E, Granovsky, Y, Ben-Nun, A, Sprecher, E, Best, LA, Granot, M Prediction of chronic post-operative pain: pre-operative DNIC testing identifies patients at risk. Pain 2008; 138:22–8 [Article] [PubMed]