Editorial Views  |   March 2000
Hemoglobin-based Oxygen-carrying Solutions : Close But Still So Far
Author Notes
  • Professor of Anesthesiology
  • Emory University School of Medicine
  • Director, Cardiothoracic Anesthesiology
  • Emory Healthcare
  • Atlanta, Georgia
Article Information
Editorial Views
Editorial Views   |   March 2000
Hemoglobin-based Oxygen-carrying Solutions : Close But Still So Far
Anesthesiology 3 2000, Vol.92, 639. doi:
Anesthesiology 3 2000, Vol.92, 639. doi:
MULTIPLE approaches are important when attempting to limit allogeneic blood transfusions. My interest in developing strategies to decrease bleeding and transfusion requirements started in the early 1980s, when I was evaluating perioperative anaphylaxis and noted that transfused blood was an important cause of life-threatening hypersensitivity reactions. 1 There are multiple reasons to reduce transfusions in addition to the risk of reactions and transfusion-related diseases. Blood products are in limited supply; they incur significant costs, expose patients to a variety of potential cellular and humoral antigens, and may alone produce either proinflammatory or even immunosuppressive responses. 1–4 A spectrum of immune alterations that persist for months has been reported after transfusion with allogeneic blood. 4 Even several milliliters of plasma present in packed erythrocytes contain sufficient numbers of donor leukoagglutinin antibodies to produce transfusion-related acute lung injury. 2,3 
In this issue of ANESTHESIOLOGY, Lamy et al.  5 report their multicenter randomized trial of diaspirin cross-linked human hemoglobin solutions as a potential alternative to blood transfusion after cardiac surgery. They note that administration of the hemoglobin-based oxygen-carrying (HBOC) solution was able to reduce the need for transfused allogenic packed erythrocytes. This finding is interesting in view of the relatively short half-life of diaspirin cross-linked hemoglobin, and its ability to reduce transfused blood cannot be explained on duration of action only.
One of the potential mechanisms by which HBOC solutions may be effective in reducing transfused blood may be a result of the fact that in hemorrhagic conditions, replenishing lost iron is difficult. Administering either oral or intravenous iron to patients is not well tolerated, free iron is toxic, and iron-containing parenteral solutions, usually bound to dextrans, have the potential to produce anaphylactic reactions. 6,7 Although the oxygen-carrying capacity of most HBOC solutions may be quite transient, they are rapidly metabolized, and free iron is potentially scavenged by multiple mechanisms to subsequently stimulate erythropoiesis and reticulocytosis. This may explain why patients were discharged with similar hematocrits in both groups, despite the reduction in transfused allogenic packed erythrocytes in the HBOC-treated patients.
Unfortunately, diaspirin-linked HBOC solutions have been abandoned because of a higher mortality that was reported when studying these solutions in trauma patients. Regrettably, the trauma patient population is a heterogeneous group of patients, and similar to therapeutic trials in sepsis, trauma patients represent a group with an extremely high morbidity and mortality incidence that can potentially complicate interpreting data. As Lamy et al.  report, an elective cardiac surgical population represents a better alternative, in which there is an established incidence of adverse events that can be easily quantified.
Based on this consideration, there are complex regulatory issues surrounding the actual approval of artificial blood products. Do the HBOC solutions need to be as good as or better than packed erythrocytes as an oxygen carrier? I believe it is important that studies of blood substitutes demonstrate that they can reduce the need for allogenic transfused blood as a determining factor for whether these agents will be approved. Another important point regarding regulatory approval of HBOC solutions includes safety. Safety studies are expensive to undertake. Although companies show “safety” in one setting and label the drug accordingly, the market place uses the drug in populations in which safety information is often unavailable.
Another important issue involving the future of HBOC solutions includes cost and availability. Current limitations include the accessibility of human hemoglobin derived from outdated banked blood, an unlikely source to provide an adequate amount of hemoglobin for commercial purposes. Recombinant DNA technology could ultimately produce modified human hemoglobin molecules. 8,9 It seems unlikely that 30 g of recombinant proteins can be manufactured to sell at a cost that is close to the current price of a unit of packed erythrocytes. The ability to economically manufacture large quantities of proteins using transgenic technology is potentially feasible, and initial transgenic studies have been reported for antithrombin III. 10 Bovine hemoglobin represents an interesting alternative that is currently in phase III studies. 8,11 The major advantage of bovine hemoglobin is its availability and large quantity. A 500-kg steer has approximately 35 l of blood containing approximately 12 g/dl of hemoglobin, for approximate total-body hemoglobin content of 4.2 kg. 8 Furthermore, bovine blood is a byproduct of most slaughterhouses and is available as an unlimited supply. Hemopure, a bovine product, is currently approved for veterinarian use.
The availability of potential replacements for blood products represents a very important consideration. In some parts of the world, the donor patient pool has an inordinately high incidence of human immunodeficiency virus infections, hepatitis C, or malaria. Therefore, having a potential safe unlimited replacement for erythrocytes represents an important goal.
One additional concern regarding HBOC solutions is their potential ability to scavenge nitric oxide. 12,13 Even in the study reported by Lamy et al.  , 5 there were increases in systemic and pulmonary artery pressures. The ability of the ferric group of iron in free hemoglobin to scavenge nitric oxide from vascular endothelium represents a potential risk factor that additional data from large patient populations will have to answer. Although this has been suggested to be a potential problem, there were no adverse outcomes reported by Lamy et al.  regarding excessive nitric oxide scavenging. Perhaps in certain inflammatory disease states, such as the systemic inflammatory response syndrome, this additional nitric oxide–scavenging capability may prove useful to attenuate mediator-induced vasodilation. 1 
One day, perhaps the HBOC solutions will provide us with the ability to replace intravascular volume in cases of hemorrhagic shock and maintain oxygen delivery until surgical repair can occur. The HBOC solutions may have life-saving benefits in military and other applications. Clinical studies to allow regulatory approval of select HBOC solutions for clinical uses are still in progress. In the meantime, cardiac and orthopedic surgical patients are an important group to evaluate in clinical trials. The current data by Lamy et al.  is very important in supporting both the safety and efficacy of these agents. The incidences of adverse events were similar in both groups, and the ability of HBOC solutions to decrease the need for donor erythrocytes is a promising finding. Additional studies will be required to have these agents readily available. At the present time, we are so close but still so far.
Levy JH: Anaphylactic Reactions in Anesthesia and Intensive Care, 2nd Edition. Stoneham, Butterworth-Heinemann, 1992
Dubois M, Lotze MT, Diamond WJ, Kim YD, Flye MW, Macnamara TE: Pulmonary shunting during leukoagglutinin-induced noncardiac pulmonary edema. JAMA 1980; 244:2186–9Dubois, M Lotze, MT Diamond, WJ Kim, YD Flye, MW Macnamara, TE
Popovsky MA, Moore SB: Diagnostic and pathogenetic considerations in transfusion-related acute lung injury. Transfusion 1985; 25:573–7Popovsky, MA Moore, SB
Klein HG: Immunomodulatory aspects of transfusion: A once and future risk? A NESTHESIOLOGY 1999; 91:861–5Klein, HG
Lamy ML, Daily EK, Brichant J-F, Larbuisson RP, Demeyere RH, Vandermeersch EA, Lehot J-J, Parsloe MR, Berridge JC, Sinclair CJ, Baron J-F, Przybelski RJ, for the DCLHb Cardiac Surgery Trial Collaborative Group: Randomized trial of diaspirin cross-linked hemoglobin solution as an alternative to blood transfusion after cardiac surgery. A NESTHESIOLOGY 2000; 92:646–56Lamy, ML Daily, EK Brichant, J-F Larbuisson, RP Demeyere, RH Vandermeersch, EA Lehot, J-J Parsloe, MR Berridge, JC Sinclair, CJ Baron, J-F Przybelski, RJ for the DCLHb Cardiac Surgery Trial Collaborative Group,
Novey HS, Pahl M, Haydik I, Vaziri ND: Immunologic studies of anaphylaxis to iron dextran in patients on renal dialysis. Ann Allergy 1994; 72:224–8Novey, HS Pahl, M Haydik, I Vaziri, ND
Faich G, Strobos J: Sodium ferric gluconate complex in sucrose: Safer intravenous iron therapy than iron dextrans. Am J Kidney Dis 1999; 33:464–70Faich, G Strobos, J
Dietz N, Joyner MJ, Warner M: Blood substitutes: Fluids, drugs, or miracle solutions? Anesth Analg 1996; 82:390–405Dietz, N Joyner, MJ Warner, M
Looker D, Abbott-Brown D, Cozart P: A human recombinant haemoglobin designed for use as a “blood substitute.” Nature 1992; 356:258–60Looker, D Abbott-Brown, D Cozart, P
Levy JH, Despotis GJ, Olson PJ, Weisinger A, Szlam F: Transgenically produced recombinant human ATIII enhances the antithrombotic effects of heparin in patients undergoing cardiac surgery. Blood 1997; 90(Suppl 1):298ALevy, JH Despotis, GJ Olson, PJ Weisinger, A Szlam, F
Levy JH, Goodnough LT, Grelich P, Parr G, Steward RW, Gratz I, Wahr J, Williams J, Comunale M, Vlahakes G: A room temperature stable hemoglobin (HBOC-201) eliminates allogeneic red blood cell transfusion in postoperative cardiac surgery patients (abstract). Circulation 1998; 98:I-132Levy, JH Goodnough, LT Grelich, P Parr, G Steward, RW Gratz, I Wahr, J Williams, J Comunale, M Vlahakes, G
Loscalzo J: Nitric oxide binding and the adverse effects of cell-free hemoglobins: What makes us different from earthworms. J Lab Clin Med 1997; 129:580–3Loscalzo, J
Hess JR, MacDonald VW, Brinkley WW: Systemic and pulmonary hypertension after resuscitation with cell-free hemoglobin. J Appl Physiol 1993; 74:1769–78Hess, JR MacDonald, VW Brinkley, WW