Correspondence  |   October 2001
The Substitute for the Intravenous Route
Author Affiliations & Notes
  • François Donati, Ph.D., M.D., F.R.C.P.C.
  • *Université de Montréal, Hôpital Maisonneuve-Rosemont, Montréal, Québec, Canada.
Article Information
Correspondence   |   October 2001
The Substitute for the Intravenous Route
Anesthesiology 10 2001, Vol.95, 1041. doi:
Anesthesiology 10 2001, Vol.95, 1041. doi:
In Reply:—
We appreciate the opportunity to respond to the excellent comments made about our editorial. The situation of laryngospasm without previous intravenous access is difficult to tackle, and the fact that two very different suggestions were made in letters to the editor indicates that the answers are not easy. Drs. Weiss and Gerber propose the intraosseous route, and Dr. Warner suggests using intramuscular succinylcholine. As we have mentioned, all possible strategies to relieve laryngospasm should be considered. 1 The option retained by the individual practitioner will depend on experience and skill. However, we wish to point out that the intraosseous route involves more complications than the intravenous route, and its use should be limited to emergency situations. Extravasation, 2 compartment syndrome, 3 and osteomyelitis 4 have been reported. In fact, one of the references quoted by Drs. Weiss and Gerber suggests an inhalational induction with halothane and nitrous oxide with intramuscular pancuronium in a case of a child with difficult intravenous access instead of intraosseous infusion of drugs. 5 In this case, securing intraosseous access is probably better than intramuscular pancuronium, a drug whose dosage and time course is not known when administered via  this route. In emergency situations, the body of evidence suggests that if one chooses to administer intramuscular relaxants, succinylcholine is the best choice. The time course of blockade is faster than with rapacuronium, which is faster than rocuronium. Intramuscular pancuronium is probably even slower. Rapacuronium has recently been withdrawn. We fully agree with Dr. Warner that the potential benefits of succinylcholine (relief of laryngospasm) outweigh its risks in a hypoxic child. Contrary to nondepolarizing muscle relaxants, laryngeal muscles are particularly sensitive to succinylcholine. 6 It would be an error to remove succinylcholine from our armamentarium. However, we would like to stress again that both the intraosseous route and intramuscular succinylcholine are not substitutes for poor planning. An intravenous line should be inserted before the airway is manipulated and before surgery commences. Intravenous access management is analogous to airway management. If one becomes familiar with several airway devices, the last resort measure (cricothyroidotomy or tracheostomy) should be learned, but hardly ever used. Similarly, if one becomes proficient at accessing the venous system at several sites, intraosseous infusions and intramuscular succinylcholine are techniques to be learned, but hopefully used infrequently.
Donati F, Guay J: No substitute for the intravenous route. A nesthesiology 2001; 94: 1–2Donati, F Guay, J
Glaeser PW, Hellmich TR, Szewczuga D, Losek JD, Smith DS: Five-year experience in prehospital intraosseous infusions in children and adults. Ann Emerg Med 1993; 22: 1119–24Glaeser, PW Hellmich, TR Szewczuga, D Losek, JD Smith, DS
Wright R, Reynolds SL, Nachtsheim B: Compartment syndrome secondary to prolonged intraosseous infusion. Pediatr Emerg Care 1994; 10: 157–9Wright, R Reynolds, SL Nachtsheim, B
Rosovsky M, FitzPatrick M, Goldfarb CR, Finestone H: Bilateral osteomyelitis due to intraosseous infusion: Case report and review of the English-language literature. Pediatr Radiol 1994; 24: 72–3Rosovsky, M FitzPatrick, M Goldfarb, CR Finestone, H
Schwartz RE, Pasquariello CA, Stayer SA: Elective use in pediatric anesthesia of intraosseous infusion: Proceed only with extreme caution. Anesth Analg 1993; 76: 918–9Schwartz, RE Pasquariello, CA Stayer, SA
Meistelman C, Plaud B, Donati F: Neuromuscular effects of succinylcholine on the vocal cords and adductor pollicis muscles. Anesth Analg 1991; 73: 278–82Meistelman, C Plaud, B Donati, F