Free
Editorial Views  |   August 2005
Injured  versus Uninjured Afferents  : Who Is to Blame for Neuropathic Pain?
Author Affiliations & Notes
  • Matthias Ringkamp, M.D.
    *
  • * Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, Maryland.
Article Information
Editorial Views / Central and Peripheral Nervous Systems / Pain Medicine
Editorial Views   |   August 2005
Injured  versus Uninjured Afferents  : Who Is to Blame for Neuropathic Pain?
Anesthesiology 8 2005, Vol.103, 221-223. doi:
Anesthesiology 8 2005, Vol.103, 221-223. doi:
THE role of different classes of afferents in neuropathic pain is a controversial issue. The debate revolves around two questions: (1) What is the role of injured and uninjured afferents in neuropathic pain? (2) What is the role of myelinated and unmyelinated fibers? Although it is commonly accepted that sensitization of central pain-processing neurons is involved in neuropathic pain, it is unclear what afferents induce and maintain central sensitization under neuropathic conditions. A better understanding of the changes in injured and uninjured afferents after nerve injury is needed to improve strategies for the treatment of chronic pain. In this issue of Anesthesiology, Sapunar et al.  1 describe the electrophysiologic properties of isolated neurons from the L4 and L5 dorsal root ganglia after an L5 spinal nerve injury in rats. An advantage of the L5 spinal nerve ligation (SNL) model2 is that injured and uninjured neurons reside in different dorsal root ganglia, but their axons commingle in the sciatic nerve and target tissue (fig. 1). Like other animal models of neuropathic pain, SNL results in behavioral signs of spontaneous and stimulus evoked pain (i.e.  , mechanical and thermal hyperalgesia).
Fig. 1. Schematic drawing of the L5 spinal nerve ligation. (  A  ) In the L5 spinal nerve ligation, the ventral ramus of the L5 spinal nerve is ligated and cut proximal to the lumbar plexus. (  B  ). In the sciatic nerve, degenerating large and small L5 nerve fibers are in close proximity to uninjured nerve fibers from other spinal levels (including L4). Factors released during Wallerian degeneration of the injured fibers may affect function in uninjured nerve fibers (  arrows  ). (  C  ) Commingling of injured and uninjured nerve fibers also occurs in peripheral target tissues such as skin. Artwork provided by Ian Suk. 
Fig. 1. Schematic drawing of the L5 spinal nerve ligation. (  A  ) In the L5 spinal nerve ligation, the ventral ramus of the L5 spinal nerve is ligated and cut proximal to the lumbar plexus. (  B  ). In the sciatic nerve, degenerating large and small L5 nerve fibers are in close proximity to uninjured nerve fibers from other spinal levels (including L4). Factors released during Wallerian degeneration of the injured fibers may affect function in uninjured nerve fibers (  arrows  ). (  C  ) Commingling of injured and uninjured nerve fibers also occurs in peripheral target tissues such as skin. Artwork provided by Ian Suk. 
Fig. 1. Schematic drawing of the L5 spinal nerve ligation. (  A  ) In the L5 spinal nerve ligation, the ventral ramus of the L5 spinal nerve is ligated and cut proximal to the lumbar plexus. (  B  ). In the sciatic nerve, degenerating large and small L5 nerve fibers are in close proximity to uninjured nerve fibers from other spinal levels (including L4). Factors released during Wallerian degeneration of the injured fibers may affect function in uninjured nerve fibers (  arrows  ). (  C  ) Commingling of injured and uninjured nerve fibers also occurs in peripheral target tissues such as skin. Artwork provided by Ian Suk. 
×
What is the evidence that injured afferents are to blame for neuropathic pain? An obvious clinical example comes from patients with a traumatic nerve lesion that resulted in the development of a neuroma: Touching or tapping the neuroma produces paraesthesia and pain. Injection of local anesthetics at the site of the nerve injury may relieve not only ongoing pain but also mechanical hyperalgesia in the surrounding skin.3 Neuroma resection and relocation of the proximal nerve end may also produce pain relief in these patients. In animal neuroma models, ectopic mechanical sensitivity, thermosensitivity, and chemosensitivity as well as spontaneous activity are found in injured myelinated and  unmyelinated afferents,4 and this is thought to be the neuronal basis of pain generated from neuromas in humans.
Similar to other lesions of peripheral nerves, SNL results in neuroma formation. After SNL, however, development of spontaneous activity in injured afferents is restricted to myelinated nerve fibers, because it seems to be absent in injured unmyelinated afferents.5 The article by Sapunar et al.  provides additional evidence that myelinated (but not unmyelinated) injured (but not uninjured) neurons develop enhanced excitability. Input from injured afferents seems to be important for the neuropathic pain behavior because application of tetrodotoxin to the L5 dorsal root ganglion reduces signs of mechanical hyperalgesia after SNL6 and because application of neomycin or gadolinium to the proximal, cut end of the L5 spinal nerve immediately after injury prevents or diminishes signs of mechanical hyperalgesia.7 Signs of mechanical hyperalgesia develop within hours after the lesion, similar to development of spontaneous activity in injured myelinated afferents, suggesting a causal link between the two.5 Studies that have used dorsal rhizotomies in the SNL model to directly investigate the role of injured afferents in neuropathic pain have unfortunately led to contradictory results: Some found reversal of neuropathic pain behavior,8 whereas others reported that an L5 dorsal rhizotomy did not prevent or reverse mechanical hyperalgesia.9 The interpretation of these data are complicated by the finding that dorsal rhizotomy by itself can produce signs of neuropathic pain.10 
Is there a role for injured, unmyelinated  afferents in neuropathic pain? Evidence for a role comes from the observation that artemin reversed the behavioral signs of neuropathic pain11 and normalized the SNL-induced changes in small L5 DRG neurons as well (e.g.  , IB4 binding; expression of P2X3, CGRP, galanin, and NPY). Artemin is a member of the glial-derived neurotrophic factor family, and the accessory protein GFRα3, through which it signals, is predominantly expressed in unmyelinated, nociceptive primary afferent neurons.12 
The presence of mechanical hyperalgesia after an L5 ganglionectomy13 or an L5 ventral rhizotomy13,14 is direct evidence for a role of uninjured  afferents in neuropathic pain. Both manipulations exclude injured primary afferents as contributors to neuropathic pain because either the soma of the injured neuron is removed (ganglionectomy) or only motor efferents are injured (ventral rhizotomy). Furthermore, there is accumulating indirect evidence for a role of uninjured afferents in neuropathic pain. The following evidence was mainly but not exclusively obtained in the SNL model. Uninjured afferents develop adrenergic sensitivity15,16 and an increased sensitivity to tumor necrosis factor α.17 Uninjured afferents also up-regulate neuropeptides,18,19 neurotrophic factors,20,21 and signal transduction proteins (e.g.  , TRPV1).22 After L5 spinal nerve injury, the percentage of cold-sensitive neurons in the L4 DRG is increased,23 and the responsiveness of uninjured, unmyelinated L4 afferents to natural stimuli is augmented.24 NaV1.8, a tetrodotoxin-resistant sodium channel, is redistributed into the peripheral axons of uninjured afferents after spinal nerve injury.25 Antisense oligonucleotides directed against NaV1.8 reverse neuropathic pain in the SNL model.25 Morphologic studies furthermore suggest that uninjured, unmyelinated afferents sprout into the “injured” L5 spinal cord segment.26 In vivo  recordings from the L4 dorsal root, L4 spinal nerve, or peripheral primary afferents have shown that uninjured myelinated and unmyelinated nerve fibers develop spontaneous activity after spinal nerve injury.16,27,28 Spontaneous activity in uninjured, unmyelinated nociceptive afferents was present in rats within 24 h after SNL. Although the rate of discharge was low, approximately half of the unmyelinated fibers showed spontaneous activity; therefore, this low rate of discharge could be sufficient to induce central sensitization. Microneurographic recordings from unmyelinated fibers in patients with neuropathic pain reveal that mechanically insensitive afferents become spontaneously active and responsive to mechanical stimuli.29 
The mechanisms inducing changes in uninjured afferents are not understood. Because intact axons commingle with degenerating axons, factors associated with Wallerian degeneration may be involved. Neuropathic pain behavior is reduced in situations where Wallerian degeneration is delayed or diminished.30,31 Wallerian degeneration leads to the generation of multiple factors, some of which are classic inflammatory mediators known to excite or to sensitize nociceptive afferents. Some of these mediators are released within hours after peripheral nerve lesion32 and therefore could induce the early changes seen in uninjured L4 afferents after L5 SNL.
Changes in uninjured afferents may also occur and contribute to neuropathic pain accompanying infectious (e.g.  , human immunodeficiency virus, herpes zoster) and metabolic (e.g.  , diabetes) diseases or in neuropathy due to drug treatment (e.g.  , vincristine). In neuropathic pain, several etiologies may be at work simultaneously: the primary disease (e.g.  , trauma, diabetes) and secondary events (e.g.  , Wallerian degeneration). The relative importance of these factors to the development and maintenance of neuropathic pain remains to be resolved.
* Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, Maryland.
References
Sapunar D, Ljubkovic M, Lirk P, McCallum J, Hogan QH: Distinct membrane effects of spinal nerve ligation on injured and adjacent dorsal root ganglion neurons in rat. Anesthesiology 2005; 103:360–76Sapunar, D Ljubkovic, M Lirk, P McCallum, J Hogan, QH
Kim SH, Chung JM: An experimental model for peripheral neuropathy produced by segmental spinal nerve ligation in the rat. Pain 1992; 50:355–63Kim, SH Chung, JM
Gracely RH, Lynch SA, Bennett GJ: Painful neuropathy: Altered central processing maintained dynamically by peripheral input. Pain 1992; 51:175–94Gracely, RH Lynch, SA Bennett, GJ
Devor M, Seltzer Z: Pathophysiology of damaged nerves in relation to chronic pain, Textbook of Pain, 4th edition. Edited by Wall PD, Melzak R. Edinburgh, United Kingdom, Churchill Livingstone, 1999, pp 129–64Devor, M Seltzer, Z Pathophysiology of damaged nerves in relation to chronic pain,Wall PD, Melzak R Edinburgh, United Kingdom Churchill Livingstone
Liu C-N, Wall PD, Ben Dor E, Michaelis M, Amir R, Devor M: Tactile allodynia in the absence of C-fiber activation: Altered firing properties of DRG neurons following spinal nerve injury. Pain 2000; 85:503–21Liu, CN Wall, PD Ben Dor, E Michaelis, M Amir, R Devor, M
Lyu YS, Park SK, Chung K, Chung JM: Low dose of tetrodotoxin reduces neuropathic pain behaviors in an animal model. Brain Res 2000; 871:98–103Lyu, YS Park, SK Chung, K Chung, JM
Blenk K-H, Häbler H-J, Jänig W: Neomycin and gadolinium applied to an L5 spinal nerve lesion prevent mechanical allodynia-like behaviour in rats. Pain 1997; 70:155–65Blenk, KH Häbler, HJ Jänig, W
Yoon YW, Na HS, Chung JM: Contributions of injured and intact afferents to neuropathic pain in an experimental rat model. Pain 1996; 64:27–36Yoon, YW Na, HS Chung, JM
Li Y, Dorsi MJ, Meyer RA, Belzberg AJ: Mechanical hyperalgesia after an L5 spinal nerve lesion in the rat is not dependent on input from injured nerve fibers. Pain 2000; 85:493–502Li, Y Dorsi, MJ Meyer, RA Belzberg, AJ
Eschenfelder S, Häbler H-J, Jänig W: Dorsal root section elicits signs of neuropathic pain rather than reversing them in rats with L5 spinal nerve injury. Pain 2000; 87:213–9Eschenfelder, S Häbler, HJ Jänig, W
Gardell LR, Wang R, Ehrenfels C, Ossipov MH, Rossomando AJ, Miller S, Buckley C, Cai AK, Tse A, Foley SF, Gong B, Walus L, Carmillo P, Worley D, Huang C, Engber T, Pepinsky B, Cate RL, Vanderah TW, Lai J, Sah DW, Porreca F: Multiple actions of systemic artemin in experimental neuropathy. Nat Med 2003; 9:1383–9Gardell, LR Wang, R Ehrenfels, C Ossipov, MH Rossomando, AJ Miller, S Buckley, C Cai, AK Tse, A Foley, SF Gong, B Walus, L Carmillo, P Worley, D Huang, C Engber, T Pepinsky, B Cate, RL Vanderah, TW Lai, J Sah, DW Porreca, F
Orozco OE, Walus L, Sah DW, Pepinsky RB, Sanicola M: GFRalpha3 is expressed predominantly in nociceptive sensory neurons. Eur J Neurosci 2001; 13:2177–82Orozco, OE Walus, L Sah, DW Pepinsky, RB Sanicola, M
Sheth RN, Dorsi MJ, Li Y, Murinson BB, Belzberg AJ, Griffin JW, Meyer RA: Mechanical hyperalgesia after an L5 ventral rhizotomy or an L5 ganglionectomy in the rat. Pain 2002; 96:63–72Sheth, RN Dorsi, MJ Li, Y Murinson, BB Belzberg, AJ Griffin, JW Meyer, RA
Li L, Xian CJ, Zhong JH, Zhou XF: Effect of lumbar 5 ventral root transection on pain behaviors: A novel rat model for neuropathic pain without axotomy of primary sensory neurons. Exp Neurol 2002; 175:23–34Li, L Xian, CJ Zhong, JH Zhou, XF
Sato J, Perl ER: Adrenergic excitation of cutaneous pain receptors induced by peripheral nerve injury. Science 1991; 251:1608–10Sato, J Perl, ER
Ali Z, Ringkamp M, Hartke TV, Chien HF, Flavahan NA, Campbell JN, Meyer RA: Uninjured C-fiber nociceptors develop spontaneous activity and alpha adrenergic sensitivity following L6 spinal nerve ligation in the monkey. J Neurophysiol 1999; 81:455–66Ali, Z Ringkamp, M Hartke, TV Chien, HF Flavahan, NA Campbell, JN Meyer, RA
Schäfers M, Lee DH, Brors D, Yaksh TL, Sorkin LS: Increased sensitivity of injured and adjacent uninjured rat primary sensory neurons to exogenous tumor necrosis factor-alpha after spinal nerve ligation. J Neurosci 2003; 23:3028–38Schäfers, M Lee, DH Brors, D Yaksh, TL Sorkin, LS
Ma W, Bisby MA: Increase of preprotachykinin mRNA and substance P immunoreactivity in spared dorsal root ganglion neurons following partial sciatic nerve injury. Eur J Neurosci 1998; 10:2388–99Ma, W Bisby, MA
Fukuoka T, Tokunaga A, Kondo E, Miki K, Tachibana T, Noguchi K: Change in mRNAs for neuropeptides and the GABA(A) receptor in dorsal root ganglion neurons in a rat experimental neuropathic pain model. Pain 1998; 78:13–26Fukuoka, T Tokunaga, A Kondo, E Miki, K Tachibana, T Noguchi, K
Fukuoka T, Kondo E, Dai Y, Hashimoto N, Noguchi K: Brain-derived neurotrophic factor increases in the uninjured dorsal root ganglion neurons in selective spinal nerve ligation model. J Neurosci 2001; 21:4891–900Fukuoka, T Kondo, E Dai, Y Hashimoto, N Noguchi, K
Fukuoka T, Tokunaga A, Kondo E, Noguchi K: The role of neighboring intact dorsal root ganglion neurons in a rat neuropathic pain model, Progress in Pain Research and Management. Edited by Devor M, Rowbotham M, Wiesenfeld-Hallin Z. Seattle, IASP Press, 2000, pp 137–46Fukuoka, T Tokunaga, A Kondo, E Noguchi, K The role of neighboring intact dorsal root ganglion neurons in a rat neuropathic pain model,Devor M, Rowbotham M, Wiesenfeld-Hallin Z Seattle IASP Press
Hudson LJ, Bevan S, Wotherspoon G, Gentry C, Fox A, Winter J: VR1 protein expression increases in undamaged DRG neurons after partial nerve injury. Eur J Neurosci 2001; 13:2105–14Hudson, LJ Bevan, S Wotherspoon, G Gentry, C Fox, A Winter, J
Djouhri L, Wrigley D, Thut PD, Gold MS: Spinal nerve injury increases the percentage of cold-responsive DRG neurons. Neuroreport 2004; 15:457–60Djouhri, L Wrigley, D Thut, PD Gold, MS
Shim B, Kim DW, Kim BH, Nam TS, Leem JW, Chung JM: Mechanical and heat sensitization of cutaneous nociceptors in rats with experimental peripheral neuropathy. Neuroscience 2005; 132:193–201Shim, B Kim, DW Kim, BH Nam, TS Leem, JW Chung, JM
Gold MS, Weinreich D, Kim CS, Wang R, Treanor J, Porreca F, Lai J: Redistribution of NaV1.8 in uninjured axons enables neuropathic pain. J Neurosci 2003; 23:158–66Gold, MS Weinreich, D Kim, CS Wang, R Treanor, J Porreca, F Lai, J
Hu J, Mata M, Hao S, Zhang G, Fink DJ: Central sprouting of uninjured small fiber afferents in the adult rat spinal cord following spinal nerve ligation. Eur J Neurosci 2004; 20:1705–12Hu, J Mata, M Hao, S Zhang, G Fink, DJ
Boucher TJ, Okuse K, Bennett DL, Munson JB, Wood JN, McMahon SB: Potent analgesic effects of GDNF in neuropathic pain states. Science 2000; 290:124–7Boucher, TJ Okuse, K Bennett, DL Munson, JB Wood, JN McMahon, SB
Wu G, Ringkamp M, Hartke TV, Murinson BB, Campbell JN, Griffin JW, Meyer RA: Early onset of spontaneous activity in uninjured C-fiber nociceptors after injury to neighboring nerve fibers. J Neurosci 2001; 21:RC140Wu, G Ringkamp, M Hartke, TV Murinson, BB Campbell, JN Griffin, JW Meyer, RA
Ørstavik, K, Weidner C, Schmidt R, Schmelz M, Hilliges M, Jørum E, Handwerker H, Torebjörk E: Pathological C-fibres in patients with a chronic painful condition. Brain 2003; 126:567–78Ørstavik, K Weidner, C Schmidt, R Schmelz, M Hilliges, M Jørum, E Handwerker, H Torebjörk, E
Ramer MS, French GD, Bisby MA: Wallerian degeneration is required for both neuropathic pain and sympathetic sprouting into the DRG. Pain 1997; 72:71–8Ramer, MS French, GD Bisby, MA
Wagner R, Heckman HM, Myers RR: Wallerian degeneration and hyperalgesia after peripheral nerve injury are glutathione-dependent. Pain 1998; 77:173–9Wagner, R Heckman, HM Myers, RR
Shamash S, Reichert F, Rotshenker S: The cytokine network of Wallerian degeneration: Tumor necrosis factor-alpha, interleukin-1α, and interleukin-1β. J Neurosci 2002; 22:223–224Shamash, S Reichert, F Rotshenker, S
Fig. 1. Schematic drawing of the L5 spinal nerve ligation. (  A  ) In the L5 spinal nerve ligation, the ventral ramus of the L5 spinal nerve is ligated and cut proximal to the lumbar plexus. (  B  ). In the sciatic nerve, degenerating large and small L5 nerve fibers are in close proximity to uninjured nerve fibers from other spinal levels (including L4). Factors released during Wallerian degeneration of the injured fibers may affect function in uninjured nerve fibers (  arrows  ). (  C  ) Commingling of injured and uninjured nerve fibers also occurs in peripheral target tissues such as skin. Artwork provided by Ian Suk. 
Fig. 1. Schematic drawing of the L5 spinal nerve ligation. (  A  ) In the L5 spinal nerve ligation, the ventral ramus of the L5 spinal nerve is ligated and cut proximal to the lumbar plexus. (  B  ). In the sciatic nerve, degenerating large and small L5 nerve fibers are in close proximity to uninjured nerve fibers from other spinal levels (including L4). Factors released during Wallerian degeneration of the injured fibers may affect function in uninjured nerve fibers (  arrows  ). (  C  ) Commingling of injured and uninjured nerve fibers also occurs in peripheral target tissues such as skin. Artwork provided by Ian Suk. 
Fig. 1. Schematic drawing of the L5 spinal nerve ligation. (  A  ) In the L5 spinal nerve ligation, the ventral ramus of the L5 spinal nerve is ligated and cut proximal to the lumbar plexus. (  B  ). In the sciatic nerve, degenerating large and small L5 nerve fibers are in close proximity to uninjured nerve fibers from other spinal levels (including L4). Factors released during Wallerian degeneration of the injured fibers may affect function in uninjured nerve fibers (  arrows  ). (  C  ) Commingling of injured and uninjured nerve fibers also occurs in peripheral target tissues such as skin. Artwork provided by Ian Suk. 
×